A person who has read a translation of Bukhari Shareef, quotes several Hadith narrations as proof for his claim that ghusl is not Waajib if semen is n

Answer

For fourteen centuries since the inception of Islam, has the Ummah understood and believed that ghusl of janaabat is the compulsory consequence of sexual relations even if mani (semen) is not discharged. The act of sexual relations renders ghusl Waajib.

It is haraam for morons to read translations of Hadith kitaabs. Morons are usually accompanied by shayaateen who become their ustaadhs (teachers). These devil teachers whisper into the fossilized brains rubbish and kufr such as this moron has blurted out without thinking of the consequences of his kufr. In effect the moron is implying that the Sahaabah, the Aimmah Mujtahideen, the Ulama and Fuqaha of the Taabieen, Tabe Taabieen and of all ages had not understood the Ahaadith which the moron has cited from the translation of Bukhari Shareef. In fact the moron displays conspiculously his jahaalat by saying 'Buhary'. He is not aware of even the proper name of Imaam Bukhari (rahmatullah alayh), hence he says 'Buhary'.

The moron denies the validity of the Consensus (Ijma') of all Four Math-habs and of even deviant sects on this issue. The Sahaabah, Taabieen, Tabe Taabieen, the Fuqaha-e-Mujtahideen, the Muhadditheen, Mufassireen and the illustrious Four Imaams – all of them – according to the moron wallowing in the darkness of kufr, have failed to understand the Ahaadith which he has cited for his corrupt and haraam opinion which is the product of his jahaalat, and only he who excels in the attribute of sensorial density has understood this mas'alah today, in this belated century – fourteen hundred years after the inception of Islam. The entire Ummah according to the stupid supposition of the moron had laboured in error and deviation for 14 centuries while he (the jaahil) has appeared as the 'mujaddid' to unravel a 'mystery' which had remained locked on the Sahaabah and the entire Ummah.

There is no need to present an academic exposition for the Ahaadith cited by the moron. This is neither the occasion for it nor is the audience equipped with the necessary knowledge for comprehension. There are numerous Ahaadith which no longer – that is from the age of the Sahaabah – have practical application. For example, there are Saheeh (authentic) Ahaadith which clearly state that wudhu is necessary after eating cooked food. Such narrations are not meant for morons. In fact, it is haraam for morons to read translations of the Hadith books, and even of the Qur'aan Majeed. They lose their Imaan in the process of their stupid reading.