The Majlis Archive

Sects - Organisations - Scholars Al-Haq Bulletin No. 46, p.2

You wrote: 'Muslims killing Muslims'. But if we have IS with their clear stated goal, and on the other side with the kuffaar coalition, Muslims that h

Question

You wrote: 'Muslims killing Muslims'. But if we have IS with their clear stated goal, and on the other side with the kuffaar coalition, Muslims that have allied to the kuffaar and themselves are killing Muslims and obstructing the ambitions of IS's to implement Shariah law, then is it really wrong to kill those Muslims who themselves do not rule by Islamic Shariah, but follow secular constitutions and allied themselves to the kuffaar. How can you engage and defend against the coalition that have these modernist secular Muslims embedded?

Answer

The issue is not so simplistic as you put it. In fact, your argument is deceptive. Firstly, ISIS initiated its genocide of the Yazidi and Christian communities, the day it began its offensive, long before the formation of the U.S. coalition. These non-Muslims were living in the land peacefully since the era of the Khulafa-e-Raashideen, and enjoyed their peaceful status during all three successive Khilaafate eras, and this position continued until the arrival yesterday of the ISIS murderers.

Secondly, ISIS began killing its own breed of Salafis even before it established its self in Mosul which was given to it on a platter by the U.S. Thirdly, it killed the Imaams and others solely because they refused to swear the oath of fealty and allegiance to Mr. Simon, Obama's 'caliph'. These Imaams and Sheikhs had no truck with the U.S. coalition which had not yet come into operation. They were not fighters. They did not fight ISIS.

Fourthly, the group, Jabhatun Nusrah of which Mr. Simon was a member a year ago, is not part of the U.S. coalition nor does it support the coalition. But, most of the Muslims killed by ISIS are the mujaahideen of Jabhatun Nusrah.

Fifthly, the 'shariah' law of ISIS is largely confined to killing people, displaying their murderous misdeeds on haraam television, haraam video and haraam internet programmes.

Sixthly, it has branded Hamas and Ikhwaanul Muslimeen (Morsi and & Co.) as murtads and kuffaar. With which U.S./Kuffaar are these two groups affiliated? Sixthly, if we employ hallucination and dupe ourselves to believe that ISIS has introduced Islamic Law, the fact remains that ISIS is a U.S. creation to promote and establish the objectives of the U.S. plot while the U.S. coalition is designed to befool the unwary and the ignorant. Brother, your gaze is focused only on an outer veneer of ISIS. You are not aware of the deep, dark and sinister plots engineered by the U.S. and its Western partners.

View on themajlis.co.za
Published in
Al-Haq Bulletin No. 46
PDF page
2

Appears under Questions & Answers (approximate).

Was this page helpful?