Question
The Majlis has severely criticized Shaikh Ibn Taimiyyah even accusing him of kufr. However, some senior Ulama of Deoband address him with the title of Shaikhul Islam. Can you explain the discrepancy?
Answer
In fact Ibn Taimiyyah was shaikhul kufr. Those of our Ulama who referred to him as 'Shaikhul Islam' were unaware of his kufr shenanigans. Besides his difference with the Four Math-habs on many Fiqhi masaa-il, Ibn Taimiyyah had deviated drastically from Siraatul Mustaqeem when he began dabbling in Greek Philosophy.
The influence of the kufr philosophy constrained him to propound beliefs of blatant kufr. We have published a booklet on the kufr of Ibn Taimiyyah. This booklet is available on our website. Hard copies are also available.
To gain an idea of the stark kufr which Ibn Taimiyyah had propounded, we reproduce the contents list of our booklet:
INTRODUCTION 2
CHAPTER ONE 4
IBN TAIMIYYAH'S AVERMENT THAT TEMPORAL (NON-ETERNAL) ENTITIES HAVE NO BEGINNING 4
His Irrational Theory of Kufr in Muwaafaqatu Sareehil Ma'qool 6
His Self-Contradiction and Pure Shirk in Minhaajus Sunnah 9
His Brazen Kufr in Naqdu Maraatibil Ijmaa' 11
His Hypothesis of Kufr in His Sharah of the Hadith of Imraan Bin Husain 12
His Kufr Commentary of Hadithun Nuzool 12
Kufr in his Fataawa 13
Kufr in His Tafseer 13
Confirmation by the Ulama of the Kufr of Ibn Taimiyyah's Beliefs 13
Ibn Taimiyyah's Shirk in the Light of the Qur'aan 15
Ibn Taimiyyah Discarding an Authentic Hadith for His Baseless Opinion of Kufr 16
Ibn Taimiyyah, the Philosophers and the Salaf 18
Allah Ta'ala's Eternal Attributes of Ghadhab (Wrath) and Ridha (Pleasure) 20
Ibn Taimiyyah Displaying His Ignorance 22
The Absurdity of Ibn Taimiyyah's 'Hawaadith Laa Awwala Laha' Postulate 23
CHAPTER TWO 27
A SIMPLE ELABORATION 27
Al-Baani's Dissociation from Ibn Taimiyyah's Abhorrent Beliefs of Kufr and Shirk 29
Ibn Taimiyyah in Abnegation of Every Belief of Islam Related to Creation 31
The Kufr Consequence of Ibn Taimiyyah's Belief 32
Debunking All the Rubbish of Ibn Taimiyyah 35
Soul-Searching for the Salafis 37
To understand his deviation, the booklet should be read with an unbiased approach.
- Source
- themajlis.co.za
- Published in
- The Majlis Vol 28 No 06
- PDF page
- 20
Appears under IBN TAIMIYYA - SHAIKHUL KUFR (approximate).