Question
In our Masjid, they use a mike with a fixed stand for bayaans and for the Fardh Salaah. During the Salaah, the mike is positioned in such a manner that it is right in front of the imam's mouth, right by his lips. This makes it impossible for him to go into ruku or sajdah in a straight line. He has to go around the mike in order to move to the other positions. So sometimes he goes to the right other times to the left. I asked an Aalim about this and he said that the movement away from the direction of Qiblah while dodging the mike is not more than 5 degrees (I'm sceptical about this), which means that the Salaah is valid. Also since the deviation from the direction of Qiblah occurs while changing positions it is OK. The example is if you lose your balance while changing positions then Salaah doesn't break. Finally because he alternates between left and right it isn't consistent and therefore it is OK. Also the entire body didn't change direction. Is this is correct? Is the salaah valid? What should be done if the Salaah is not valid? Should I just ignore this and leave these things to the ulema?
Answer
The Aalim whom you asked has provided a fallacious answer. His explanation is pure drivel. Besides the Qiblah issue, the repeated stupid, clownish action of the Imaam when changing postures is termed Amal-e-Katheer
(excessive action) in the context of Salaat. Thus, the Salaat becomes invalid by the silly acting of the Imaam. The Salaat should be repeated. A mockery is made of this great fundamental Ibaadat. There is absolutely no khushoo' and khudhoo' in such a Salaat in which extraneous, silly antics are introduced.
Musallis should insist on dumping the mike. It is not permissible to use it for Salaat. The clownish antics further aggravate the impermissibility.
- Source
- themajlis.co.za
- Published in
- The Majlis Vol 25 No 07
- PDF page
- 7
Verbatim verified against the source PDF
Appears under CLOWNING IN SALAAT. This heading is the nearest headline at or before the page and is approximate. Do not cite it alone.